°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡û »ò ¡ú ¿É¿ìËÙÉÏÏ·ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉ쵀 Enter ¼ü¿É»Øµ½±¾ÊéĿ¼ҳ£¬°´¼üÅÌÉÏ·½Ïò¼ü ¡ü ¿É»Øµ½±¾Ò³¶¥²¿£¡
¡ª¡ª¡ª¡ªÎ´ÔĶÁÍꣿ¼ÓÈëÊéÇ©ÒѱãÏ´μÌÐøÔĶÁ£¡
rest¡¡in¡¡peace£»¡¡began¡¡to¡¡assume¡¡when¡¡he¡¡saw¡¡the¡¡last¡¡painting¡£¡¡He¡¯d¡¡been¡¡saying¡¡
that¡¡¡¡your¡¡¡¡use¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡science¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡perspective¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡methods¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡Veian¡¡
masters¡¡was¡¡nothing¡¡but¡¡the¡¡temptation¡¡of¡¡Satan¡£¡¡In¡¡the¡¡last¡¡painting£»¡¡you¡¯ve¡¡
supposedly¡¡rendered¡¡the¡¡face¡¡of¡¡a¡¡mortal¡¡using¡¡the¡¡Frankish¡¡techniques£»¡¡so¡¡the¡¡
observer¡¡has¡¡the¡¡impression¡¡not¡¡of¡¡a¡¡painting¡¡but¡¡of¡¡reality£»¡¡to¡¡such¡¡a¡¡degree¡¡
that¡¡this¡¡image¡¡has¡¡the¡¡power¡¡to¡¡entice¡¡men¡¡to¡¡bow¡¡down¡¡before¡¡it£»¡¡as¡¡with¡¡
icons¡¡in¡¡churches¡£¡¡According¡¡to¡¡him£»¡¡this¡¡is¡¡the¡¡Devil¡¯s¡¡work£»¡¡not¡¡only¡¡because¡¡
the¡¡art¡¡of¡¡perspective¡¡removes¡¡the¡¡painting¡¡from¡¡God¡¯s¡¡perspective¡¡and¡¡lowers¡¡
it¡¡to¡¡the¡¡level¡¡of¡¡a¡¡street¡¡dog£»¡¡but¡¡because¡¡your¡¡reliance¡¡on¡¡the¡¡methods¡¡of¡¡the¡¡
Veians¡¡as¡¡well¡¡as¡¡your¡¡mingling¡¡of¡¡our¡¡own¡¡established¡¡traditions¡¡with¡¡that¡¡
of¡¡the¡¡infidels¡¡will¡¡strip¡¡us¡¡of¡¡our¡¡purity¡¡and¡¡reduce¡¡us¡¡to¡¡being¡¡their¡¡slaves¡£¡±¡¡
¡°Nothing¡¡¡¡is¡¡¡¡pure£»¡±¡¡¡¡said¡¡¡¡Enishte¡¡¡¡Effendi¡£¡¡¡¡¡°In¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡realm¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡book¡¡¡¡arts£»¡¡
whenever¡¡a¡¡masterpiece¡¡is¡¡made£»¡¡whenever¡¡a¡¡splendid¡¡picture¡¡makes¡¡my¡¡eyes¡¡
water¡¡out¡¡of¡¡joy¡¡and¡¡causes¡¡a¡¡chill¡¡to¡¡run¡¡down¡¡my¡¡spine£»¡¡I¡¡can¡¡be¡¡certain¡¡of¡¡
the¡¡¡¡following£º¡¡¡¡Two¡¡¡¡styles¡¡¡¡heretofore¡¡¡¡never¡¡¡¡brought¡¡¡¡together¡¡¡¡have¡¡¡¡e¡¡
together¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡create¡¡¡¡something¡¡¡¡new¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡wondrous¡£¡¡¡¡We¡¡¡¡owe¡¡¡¡Bihzad¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡the¡¡
splendor¡¡of¡¡Persian¡¡painting¡¡to¡¡the¡¡meeting¡¡of¡¡an¡¡Arabic¡¡illustrating¡¡sensibility¡¡
and¡¡¡¡Mongol¡Chinese¡¡¡¡painting¡£¡¡¡¡Shah¡¡¡¡Tahmasp¡¯s¡¡¡¡best¡¡¡¡paintings¡¡¡¡marry¡¡¡¡Persian¡¡
style¡¡¡¡with¡¡¡¡Turkmen¡¡¡¡subtleties¡£¡¡¡¡Today£»¡¡¡¡if¡¡¡¡men¡¡¡¡cannot¡¡¡¡adequately¡¡¡¡praise¡¡¡¡the¡¡
book¡arts¡¡¡¡workshops¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Akbar¡¡¡¡Khan¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡Hindustan£»¡¡¡¡it¡¯s¡¡¡¡because¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡urged¡¡¡¡his¡¡
miniaturists¡¡to¡¡adopt¡¡the¡¡styles¡¡of¡¡the¡¡Frankish¡¡masters¡£¡¡To¡¡God¡¡belongs¡¡the¡¡
East¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡West¡£¡¡¡¡May¡¡¡¡He¡¡¡¡protect¡¡¡¡us¡¡¡¡from¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡will¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡pure¡¡¡¡and¡¡
unadulterated¡£¡±¡¡
However¡¡¡¡soft¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡bright¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡face¡¡¡¡might¡¡¡¡have¡¡¡¡appeared¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡candlelight£»¡¡¡¡his¡¡
shadow£»¡¡cast¡¡on¡¡the¡¡wall£»¡¡was¡¡equally¡¡as¡¡black¡¡and¡¡frightening¡£¡¡Despite¡¡finding¡¡
what¡¡he¡¡said¡¡to¡¡be¡¡exceedingly¡¡reasonable¡¡and¡¡sound£»¡¡I¡¡didn¡¯t¡¡believe¡¡him¡£¡¡I¡¡
assumed¡¡he¡¡was¡¡suspicious¡¡of¡¡me£»¡¡and¡¡thus£»¡¡I¡¡grew¡¡suspicious¡¡of¡¡him£»¡¡I¡¡sensed¡¡
that¡¡he¡¡was¡¡listening¡¡at¡¡times¡¡for¡¡the¡¡courtyard¡¡gate¡¡below£»¡¡that¡¡he¡¡was¡¡hoping¡¡
someone¡¡would¡¡deliver¡¡him¡¡from¡¡my¡¡presence¡£¡¡
177¡¡
¡¡
¡°You¡¡¡¡yourself¡¡¡¡told¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡how¡¡¡¡Sheikh¡¡¡¡Muhammad¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡Master¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Isfahan¡¡
burned¡¡¡¡down¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡great¡¡¡¡library¡¡¡¡containing¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡paintings¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡renounced£»¡¡
and¡¡how¡¡he¡¡also¡¡immolated¡¡himself¡¡in¡¡a¡¡fit¡¡of¡¡bad¡¡conscience£»¡±¡¡he¡¡said¡£¡¡¡°Now¡¡
let¡¡me¡¡tell¡¡you¡¡another¡¡story¡¡related¡¡to¡¡that¡¡legend¡¡that¡¡you¡¡don¡¯t¡¡know¡£¡¡It¡¯s¡¡
true£»¡¡he¡¯d¡¡spent¡¡the¡¡last¡¡thirty¡¡years¡¡of¡¡his¡¡life¡¡hunting¡¡down¡¡his¡¡own¡¡works¡£¡¡
However£»¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡books¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡perused£»¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡increasingly¡¡¡¡discovered¡¡¡¡imitations¡¡
inspired¡¡by¡¡him¡¡rather¡¡than¡¡his¡¡original¡¡work¡£¡¡In¡¡later¡¡years£»¡¡he¡¡came¡¡to¡¡realize¡¡
that¡¡two¡¡generations¡¡of¡¡artists¡¡had¡¡adopted¡¡as¡¡models¡¡of¡¡form¡¡the¡¡illustrations¡¡
he¡¡himself¡¡had¡¡renounced£»¡¡that¡¡they¡¯d¡¡ingrained¡¡his¡¡pictures¡¡in¡¡their¡¡minds¡ª
or¡¡¡¡more¡¡¡¡accurately£»¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡made¡¡¡¡them¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡part¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡their¡¡¡¡souls¡£¡¡¡¡As¡¡¡¡Sheikh¡¡
Muhammad¡¡¡¡attempted¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡find¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡own¡¡¡¡pictures¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡destroy¡¡¡¡them£»¡¡¡¡he¡¡
discovered¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡young¡¡¡¡miniaturists¡¡¡¡had£»¡¡¡¡with¡¡¡¡reverence£»¡¡¡¡reproduced¡¡¡¡them¡¡¡¡in¡¡
countless¡¡¡¡books£»¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡relied¡¡¡¡on¡¡¡¡them¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡illustrating¡¡¡¡other¡¡¡¡stories£»¡¡¡¡had¡¡¡¡caused¡¡
them¡¡to¡¡be¡¡memorized¡¡by¡¡all¡¡and¡¡had¡¡spread¡¡them¡¡over¡¡the¡¡world¡£¡¡Over¡¡long¡¡
years£»¡¡as¡¡we¡¡gaze¡¡at¡¡book¡¡after¡¡book¡¡and¡¡illustration¡¡after¡¡illustration£»¡¡we¡¡e¡¡
to¡¡learn¡¡the¡¡following£º¡¡A¡¡great¡¡painter¡¡does¡¡not¡¡content¡¡himself¡¡by¡¡affecting¡¡us¡¡
with¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡masterpieces£»¡¡¡¡ultimately£»¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡succeeds¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡changing¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡landscape¡¡¡¡of¡¡
our¡¡minds¡£¡¡Once¡¡a¡¡miniaturist¡¯s¡¡artistry¡¡enters¡¡our¡¡souls¡¡this¡¡way£»¡¡it¡¡bees¡¡
the¡¡criterion¡¡for¡¡the¡¡beauty¡¡of¡¡our¡¡world¡£¡¡At¡¡the¡¡end¡¡of¡¡his¡¡life£»¡¡as¡¡the¡¡Master¡¡
of¡¡Isfahan¡¡burned¡¡his¡¡own¡¡art£»¡¡he¡¡not¡¡only¡¡witnessed¡¡the¡¡fact¡¡that¡¡his¡¡work£»¡¡
instead¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡disappearing£»¡¡¡¡actually¡¡¡¡proliferated¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡increased£»¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡understood¡¡
that¡¡everybody¡¡now¡¡saw¡¡the¡¡world¡¡the¡¡way¡¡he¡¡had¡¡seen¡¡it¡£¡¡Those¡¡things¡¡which¡¡
did¡¡¡¡not¡¡¡¡resemble¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡paintings¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡made¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡youth¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡now¡¡¡¡considered¡¡
ugly¡£¡±¡¡
Unable¡¡to¡¡rein¡¡in¡¡the¡¡awe¡¡stirring¡¡within¡¡me¡¡and¡¡to¡¡control¡¡my¡¡desire¡¡to¡¡
please¡¡¡¡Enishte¡¡¡¡Effendi£»¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡fell¡¡¡¡before¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡knees¡£¡¡¡¡As¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡kissed¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡hand£»¡¡¡¡my¡¡¡¡eyes¡¡
filled¡¡with¡¡tears¡¡and¡¡I¡¡felt¡¡I¡¡had¡¡relinquished¡¡to¡¡him¡¡the¡¡place¡¡in¡¡my¡¡soul¡¡that¡¡
had¡¡always¡¡been¡¡reserved¡¡for¡¡Master¡¡Osman¡£¡¡
¡°A¡¡¡¡miniaturist£»¡±¡¡¡¡said¡¡¡¡Enishte¡¡¡¡Effendi¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡tone¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡self¡satisfied¡¡¡¡man£»¡¡
¡°creates¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡art¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡heeding¡¡¡¡his¡¡¡¡conscience¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡by¡¡¡¡obeying¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡principles¡¡¡¡in¡¡
which¡¡he¡¡believes£»¡¡fearing¡¡nothing¡£¡¡He¡¡pays¡¡no¡¡attention¡¡to¡¡what¡¡his¡¡enemies£»¡¡
the¡¡zealots¡¡and¡¡those¡¡who¡¡envy¡¡him¡¡have¡¡to¡¡say¡£¡±¡¡
But¡¡¡¡it¡¡¡¡occurred¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡Enishte¡¡¡¡Effendi¡¡¡¡wasn¡¯t¡¡¡¡even¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡miniaturist¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡I¡¡
kissed¡¡his¡¡aged¡¡and¡¡mottled¡¡hand¡¡through¡¡my¡¡tears¡£¡¡I¡¡was¡¡embarrassed¡¡by¡¡my¡¡
thought¡£¡¡It¡¡was¡¡as¡¡if¡¡another¡¡had¡¡forced¡¡this¡¡devilish£»¡¡shameless¡¡notion¡¡into¡¡my¡¡
head¡£¡¡Even¡¡so£»¡¡you¡¡too¡¡know¡¡how¡¡true¡¡this¡¡statement¡¡is¡£¡¡
¡°I¡¯m¡¡not¡¡afraid¡¡of¡¡them£»¡±¡¡Enishte¡¡said£»¡¡¡°because¡¡I¡¯m¡¡not¡¡afraid¡¡of¡¡death¡£¡±¡¡
178¡¡
¡¡
Who¡¡¡¡were¡¡¡¡¡°they¡±£¿¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡nodded¡¡¡¡as¡¡¡¡if¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡understood¡£¡¡¡¡Yet¡¡¡¡annoyance¡¡¡¡began¡¡¡¡to¡¡
mount¡¡within¡¡me¡£¡¡I¡¡noticed¡¡that¡¡the¡¡old¡¡volume¡¡immediately¡¡beside¡¡Enishte¡¡
was¡¡El¡Jevziyye¡¯s¡¡Book¡¡of¡¡the¡¡Soul¡£¡¡All¡¡dotards¡¡who¡¡seek¡¡death¡¡share¡¡a¡¡love¡¡for¡¡
this¡¡book¡¡that¡¡recounts¡¡the¡¡adventures¡¡that¡¡await¡¡the¡¡soul¡£¡¡Since¡¡I¡¯d¡¡been¡¡here¡¡
last£»¡¡I¡¡saw¡¡only¡¡one¡¡new¡¡item¡¡among¡¡the¡¡objects¡¡collected¡¡in¡¡trays£»¡¡resting¡¡on¡¡
the¡¡¡¡chest£»¡¡¡¡among¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡pen¡¡¡¡cases£»¡¡¡¡penknives£»¡¡¡¡nib¡cutting¡¡¡¡boards£»¡¡¡¡inkwells¡¡¡¡and¡¡
brushes£º¡¡a¡¡bronze¡¡inkpot¡£¡¡
¡°Let¡¯s¡¡establish£»¡¡once¡¡and¡¡for¡¡all£»¡¡that¡¡we¡¡do¡¡not¡¡fear¡¡them£»¡±¡¡I¡¡said¡¡boldly¡£¡¡
¡°Take¡¡out¡¡the¡¡last¡¡illustration¡£¡¡Let¡¯s¡¡show¡¡it¡¡to¡¡them¡£¡±¡¡
¡°But¡¡wouldn¡¯t¡¡this¡¡prove¡¡that¡¡we¡¡minded¡¡their¡¡slander£»¡¡at¡¡least¡¡enough¡¡to¡¡
take¡¡it¡¡seriously£¿¡¡We¡¯ve¡¡done¡¡nothing¡¡of¡¡which¡¡we¡¡ought¡¡to¡¡be¡¡afraid¡£¡¡What¡¡
could¡¡justify¡¡your¡¡being¡¡so¡¡frightened£¿¡±¡¡
He¡¡stroked¡¡my¡¡hair¡¡like¡¡a¡¡father¡£¡¡I¡¡was¡¡afraid¡¡that¡¡I¡¡might¡¡burst¡¡into¡¡tears¡¡
again£»¡¡I¡¡embraced¡¡him¡£¡¡
¡°I¡¡¡¡know¡¡¡¡why¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡unfortunate¡¡¡¡gilder¡¡¡¡Elegant¡¡¡¡Effendi¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡killed£»¡±¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡said¡¡
excitedly¡£¡¡¡°By¡¡slandering¡¡you£»¡¡your¡¡book¡¡and¡¡us£»¡¡Elegant¡¡Effendi¡¡was¡¡planning¡¡
to¡¡¡¡set¡¡¡¡Nusret¡¡¡¡Hoja¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡Erzurum¡¯s¡¡¡¡men¡¡¡¡upon¡¡¡¡us¡£¡¡¡¡He¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡convinced¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡we¡¯d¡¡
fallen¡¡sway¡¡to¡¡the¡¡Devil¡£¡¡He¡¯d¡¡begun¡¡spreading¡¡such¡¡rumors£»¡¡trying¡¡to¡¡incite¡¡
the¡¡¡¡other¡¡¡¡miniaturists¡¡¡¡working¡¡¡¡on¡¡¡¡your¡¡¡¡book¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡rebel¡¡¡¡against¡¡¡¡you¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡don¡¯t¡¡
know¡¡why¡¡he¡¡suddenly¡¡began¡¡to¡¡do¡¡this¡£¡¡Perhaps¡¡out¡¡of¡¡jealousy£»¡¡perhaps¡¡he¡¯d¡¡
e¡¡¡¡under¡¡¡¡Satan¡¯s¡¡¡¡influence¡£¡¡¡¡And¡¡¡¡the¡¡¡¡other¡¡¡¡miniaturists¡¡¡¡also¡¡¡¡heard¡¡¡¡how¡¡
determined¡¡Elegant¡¡Effendi¡¡was¡¡to¡¡destroy¡¡us¡¡all¡£¡¡You¡¡can¡¡imagine¡¡how¡¡each¡¡of¡¡
them¡¡grew¡¡frightened¡¡and¡¡succumbed¡¡to¡¡suspicions¡¡as¡¡I¡¡myself¡¡had¡£¡¡Because¡¡
one¡¡of¡¡their¡¡lot¡¡was¡¡cornered£»¡¡in¡¡the¡¡middle¡¡of¡¡the¡¡night£»¡¡by¡¡Elegant¡¡Effendi¡ª
who¡¡had¡¡incited¡¡him¡¡against¡¡you£»¡¡us£»¡¡our¡¡book£»¡¡as¡¡well¡¡as¡¡against¡¡illustrating£»¡¡
painting¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡all¡¡¡¡else¡¡¡¡we¡¡¡¡believe¡¡¡¡in¡ªthat¡¡¡¡artist¡¡¡¡fell¡¡¡¡into¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡panic£»¡¡¡¡killing¡¡¡¡that¡¡
scoundrel¡¡and¡¡tossing¡¡his¡¡body¡¡into¡¡a¡¡well¡£¡±¡¡
¡°Scoundrel£¿¡±¡¡
¡°Elegant¡¡Effendi¡¡was¡¡an¡¡ill¡natured£»¡¡ill¡bred¡¡traitor¡£¡¡Villain£¡¡±¡¡I¡¡shouted¡¡as¡¡if¡¡
he¡¡were¡¡before¡¡me¡¡in¡¡the¡¡room¡£¡¡
Silence¡£¡¡Did¡¡he¡¡fear¡¡me£¿¡¡I¡¡was¡¡afraid¡¡of¡¡myself¡£¡¡It¡¡was¡¡as¡¡if¡¡I¡¯d¡¡succumbed¡¡to¡¡
somebody¡¡else¡¯s¡¡will¡¡and¡¡thoughts£»¡¡yet£»¡¡this¡¡was¡¡not¡¡wholly¡¡unpleasant¡£¡¡
¡°Who¡¡was¡¡this¡¡miniaturist¡¡who¡¡fell¡¡into¡¡a¡¡panic¡¡like¡¡you¡¡and¡¡the¡¡illustrator¡¡
from¡¡Isfahan£¿¡¡Who¡¡killed¡¡him£¿¡±¡¡
¡°I¡¡don¡¯t¡¡know£»¡±¡¡I¡¡said¡£¡¡
179¡¡
¡¡
Yet¡¡I¡¡wanted¡¡him¡¡to¡¡infer¡¡from¡¡my¡¡expression¡¡that¡¡I¡¡was¡¡lying¡£¡¡I¡¡realized¡¡that¡¡
I¡¯d¡¡¡¡made¡¡¡¡a¡¡¡¡grave¡¡¡¡error¡¡¡¡in¡¡¡¡ing¡¡¡¡here£»¡¡¡¡but¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡wasn¡¯t¡¡¡¡going¡¡¡¡to¡¡¡¡succumb¡¡¡¡to¡¡
feelings¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡guilt¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡regret¡£¡¡¡¡I¡¡¡¡could¡¡¡¡see¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡Enishte¡¡¡¡Effendi¡¡¡¡was¡¡¡¡growing¡¡
suspicious¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡me¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡this¡¡¡¡pleased¡¡¡¡and¡¡¡¡fortified¡¡¡¡me¡£¡¡¡¡If¡¡¡¡he¡¡¡¡became¡¡¡¡convinced¡¡
that¡¡I¡¡was¡¡a¡¡murderer¡¡and¡¡this¡¡knowledge¡¡struck¡¡terror¡¡throughout¡¡his¡¡soul£»¡¡
then¡¡he¡¡wouldn¡¯t¡¡dare¡¡refuse¡¡to¡¡show¡¡me¡¡the¡¡final¡¡painting¡£¡¡I¡¡was¡¡so¡¡curious¡¡
about¡¡¡¡that¡¡¡¡picture£»¡¡¡¡not¡¡¡¡because¡¡¡¡of¡¡¡¡any¡¡¡¡sin¡¡¡¡I¡¯d¡¡¡¡mitted¡¡¡¡on¡¡¡¡its¡¡¡¡account¡ªI¡¡
genuinely¡¡wanted¡¡to¡¡see¡¡how¡¡it¡¯